The Decade's Defining Dilemmas: 10 Toughest Video Game Choices, Ranked

Silas Fletcher Avatar
Silas Fletcher
28 Oct 2023
The Decade's Defining Dilemmas: 10 Toughest Video Game Choices, Ranked image

As gamers, we're no strangers to the multitude of tough choices that video games present. From the seemingly simple task of naming our characters to making life-altering decisions that impact the narrative, these choices often define our gaming experiences and the emotional connections we forge with the characters.

10. Constructing Your Character's Identity

The process of character creation can be both exciting and daunting. Choosing a name that fits your character's personality and the world they inhabit can be a challenging task. Many gamers feel that their character's name plays a crucial role in immersing themselves in the game's world and narrative. It's not unusual for some players to restart their games if they feel disconnected from the name they initially chose.

9. Crafting Your Character's Appearance

After naming your character, the next challenging task is customizing their appearance. Today's games offer an array of customization options, right from hairstyles to eye color. Some games offer opportunities to alter features later, but others make these choices permanent. Players can spend hours perfecting their character's look, even in games where they rarely see their character.

8. The Walking Dead: To Support Kenny or Lily

Telltale's The Walking Dead is known for its gut-wrenching decisions. In the second episode of Season One, a situation arises where players must decide whether to support Kenny or Lily. The choice is not easy and comes with serious consequences, creating a memorable moment in the game.

7. Fallout 3: To Detonate or Not

In Fallout 3, players find themselves in Megaton, a city surviving in the shadow of an unactivated bomb. Here, players face the moral dilemma of detonating the bomb or sparing the city. While detonating the bomb yields rich rewards, it comes at the cost of the lives of the city's inhabitants.

6. The Witcher 3: The Tree Spirit Dilemma

The Witcher 3 is celebrated for its deep storytelling and complex decisions. One such decision involves whether to release an evil tree spirit or destroy it. The choice is difficult, and each option has its consequences, affecting the fate of several characters in the game.

5. Mass Effect 2: Deciding the Geths' Fate

One of the most impactful choices in the Mass Effect series occurs when players must decide to rewrite or destroy the Geth heretics. This decision not only affects the support players receive at the end of the game but also presents a moral quandary about the value of life and freedom.

4. Life Is Strange: Saving Arcadia Bay or Chloe

Life Is Strange is a game that tugs at your heartstrings with the choices it presents. In the final act, players must select between saving their closest friend, Chloe, or the town of Arcadia Bay. Both choices come with heavy consequences, making this one of the toughest decisions in video gaming.

3. Spec Ops: The Line: To Shoot or Not

Spec Ops: The Line is known for its multiple endings and moral choices. At the end of the game, players must decide whether to shoot themselves or Konrad. Each decision leads to a different ending, thus significantly affecting the narrative.

2. Ghost Of Tsushima: Spare or Not Spare Lord Shimura

In Ghost Of Tsushima, players are faced with a heartbreaking decision - to spare Lord Shimura or not. Each choice leads to a different ending, with both having severe implications on the game's narrative and emotional undertone.

1. Heavy Rain: To Drink or Not to Drink the Poison

The toughest video game choice comes in Heavy Rain, where players get to decide whether to drink a bottle of poison to gain partial data of Shaun's location or walk away. The decision is a nerve-wracking gamble that keeps players on the edge of their seats.


Video games have evolved from simple entertainment mediums to complex narrative platforms that challenge players with hard decisions. These choices not only shape the narrative but also allow us to discover and question our morals and values. They are the moments that stay with us long after we've finished playing, making them a defining aspect of our gaming experiences.

Leave a comment